Idea Statica
  • Steel
  • Concrete
  • Support & Learning
  • Pricing
  • Company
  • Steel overview
  • Connection design
  • Member design
  • Parametric design
  • Steel case studies
  • Concrete overview
  • Walls and D-regions
  • Anchoring design
  • Concrete case studies
  • BIM Overview
  • Supported integrations
  • Checkbot
  • Viewer
  • APIs
  • Support Center
  • E-learning & certification
  • Blog
  • Downloads & Licensing
  • Plans
  • Free community tool
  • Enterprise customers
  • Students & educators
  • How much will you save?
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Research & development
  • Authorized resellers
  • Meet our customers
  • Career
  • Steel
    Steel overviewConnection designMember designParametric designSteel case studies
  • Concrete
    Concrete overviewWalls and D-regionsAnchoring designConcrete case studies
  • BIM OverviewSupported integrationsCheckbotViewerAPIs
  • Support & Learning
    Support CenterE-learning & certificationBlogDownloads & Licensing
  • Pricing
    PlansFree community toolEnterprise customersStudents & educatorsHow much will you save?
  • Company
    About usContactResearch & developmentAuthorized resellersMeet our customersCareer
14-Day Trial
14-Day Trial

Subscribe to our newsletter

Company

  • About us
  • Partners
  • Careers
  • Patent

Resources

  • Customer projects
  • Case studies
  • Connection Library
  • Verification books

Legal

  • EULA
  • Privacy policy
  • California Privacy
  • TOS Viewer
  • Licensing

Help

  • Contact
  • Quote request
  • Resellers
  • Downloads
FacebookInstagramLinkedInYouTube

© IDEA StatiCa 2009-2026

Trusted and used worldwide by engineers, fabricators & consultants.

Support CenterVerification examplesFillet weld in beam to column joint
Fillet weld in beam to column joint
SteelConnection designVerificationsConnectionEN (Eurocode)

Fillet weld in beam to column joint

This article is also available in
ENCZDEESFRITPTNLHUROKRPLTHTRVIZH

This article is a selected chapter from book Component-based finite element design of steel connections by prof. Wald et al. The chapter is focused on verification of welds.

 Description

The object of this chapter is verification of component based finite element method (CBFEM) for a fillet weld in a stiffened beam-to-column joint with component method (CM). An open section beam IPE is connected to open section column HEB400. The stiffeners are inside column opposite to beam flanges. The beam section is the changing parameter. Three load cases are considered, i.e. the beam is loaded in tension, shear and bending.

 Analytical model

The fillet weld is the only component examined in the study. The welds are designed according to Chapter 4 in EN 1993-1-8:2005 to be the weakest component in the joint. The design resistance of the fillet weld is described in Section 4.1. Overview of the considered examples and the material are given in the Tab. 4.4.1. A geometry of the joint with dimensions is shown in Fig. 4.4.1.

Tab. 4.4.1 Examples overview

Hand Calculation of normal force N 

 σ⊥2 +3⋅(τ⊥2 +τ∥2)≤fuβw⋅γM2\sqrt{  \sigma_{\perp}^2  + 3 \cdot \left( \tau_{\perp}^2  + \tau_{\parallel}^2\right)} \leq \frac{f_u}{\beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}} σ⊥2​ +3⋅(τ⊥2​ +τ∥2​)​≤βw​⋅γM2​fu​​

σ⊥=τ⊥=σN2=Nl⋅a⋅12\sigma_{\perp} = \tau_{\perp} = \frac{\sigma_{N}}{\sqrt{2}} = \frac{N}{l \cdot a}\cdot \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}σ⊥​=τ⊥​=2​σN​​=l⋅aN​⋅2​1​

τ∥=0\tau_{\parallel} = 0τ∥​=0

(σN2)2+3⋅(σN2)2≤fuβw⋅γM2\sqrt{ \left( \frac{\sigma_{N}}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2 + 3 \cdot \left( \frac{\sigma_{N}}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2} \leq \frac{f_u}{\beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}}(2​σN​​)2+3⋅(2​σN​​)2​≤βw​⋅γM2​fu​​

(Nl⋅a⋅12)2+3⋅(Nl⋅a⋅12)2≤fuβw⋅γM2\sqrt{ \left( \frac{N}{l \cdot a}\cdot \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2 + 3 \cdot \left( \frac{N}{l \cdot a}\cdot \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2} \leq \frac{f_u}{\beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}}(l⋅aN​⋅2​1​)2+3⋅(l⋅aN​⋅2​1​)2​≤βw​⋅γM2​fu​​

N≤fu ⋅ l ⋅ aβw ⋅ γM2 ⋅ 2N \leq \frac{f_{u}  \cdot  l  \cdot  a }{\beta_{\mathrm{w}}  \cdot  \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}  \cdot  \sqrt{2}}N≤βw​ ⋅ γM2​ ⋅ 2​fu​ ⋅ l ⋅ a​

Where:

aaa - weld throat thickness

NNN - normal force acting on beam

lll - total welds length 

βw\beta_{\mathrm{w}}βw​ - correlation factor taken from EN 1993-1-8 Table 4.1

fuf_ufu​ - nominal ultimate tensile strength of the weaker part joined

γM2\gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}γM2​ - partial safety factor for welds

Hand Calculation of shear force V 

The manual calculation presented in this chapter is predicated on certain assumptions. The shear force VVV is transmitted exclusively by the weld at the web. The bending moment resulting from the eccentricity of the force acting on the welds can be attributed to the flange welds. The weld section modulus of flange welds WWW is determined not by the distance measured from the centre of gravity of the welds, but from the edges of the flange to the beam centre of gravity, as calculated in practice.

The following equations demonstrate the derivation of the weld load-bearing capacity for shear force and bending moment according to the CM. The equivalent stress is specified in EN 1993-1-8, Equation (4.1). For the calculation of bending moment resistance, the plastic section modulus was assumed. 

 σ⊥ +3⋅(τ⊥2 +τ∥2)≤fuβw⋅γM2\sqrt{  \sigma_{\perp}  + 3 \cdot \left( \tau_{\perp}^2  + \tau_{\parallel}^2\right)} \leq \frac{f_u}{\beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}} σ⊥​ +3⋅(τ⊥2​ +τ∥2​)​≤βw​⋅γM2​fu​​

V≤min⁡{fu⋅lV⋅a3⋅βw⋅γM2,  fu⋅W2⋅βw⋅γM2⋅e  }V \le \min \left \{ \frac{f_\mathrm{u} \cdot l_V \cdot a}{\sqrt{3} \cdot \beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{M2}} , \,  \frac{f_\mathrm{u} \cdot W}{\sqrt{2} \cdot \beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}} \cdot e}   \right \}V≤min{3​⋅βw​⋅γM2​fu​⋅lV​⋅a​, 2​⋅βw​⋅γM2​⋅efu​⋅W​  }

Where:

eee - force eccentricity relative to the beam welds 

aaa - weld throat thickness

VVV - shear force acting on beam

W=Wpl,flangeW= W_\mathrm{pl,flange}W=Wpl,flange​ - welds section modulus

Aw,top,f=B⋅aA_\mathrm{w,top,f} = B \cdot aAw,top,f​=B⋅a - top flange edge weld area 

Aw,bottom,f=(B−tw)⋅aA_\mathrm{w,bottom,f} = (B-t_\mathrm{w}) \cdot aAw,bottom,f​=(B−tw​)⋅a - bottom flange edge weld area 

zw,top,f=H/2z_\mathrm{w,top,f} = H / 2zw,top,f​=H/2 - top flange edge weld lever arm

zw,bottom,f=(H−tf)/2z_\mathrm{w,bottom,f} = (H - t_\mathrm{f}) / 2zw,bottom,f​=(H−tf​)/2 - bottom flange edge weld lever arm

Wpl,flange=2⋅(Aw,top,f⋅ zw,top,f+Aw,bottom,f⋅zw,bottom,f)W_\mathrm{pl,flange} = 2 \cdot \left(A_\mathrm{w,top,f} \cdot  z_\mathrm{w,top,f} + A_\mathrm{w,bottom,f} \cdot z_\mathrm{w,bottom,f}\right)Wpl,flange​=2⋅(Aw,top,f​⋅ zw,top,f​+Aw,bottom,f​⋅zw,bottom,f​) - plastic flange section modulus

lVl_{\mathrm{V}}lV​ - total web welds length 

βw\beta_{\mathrm{w}}βw​ - correlation factor taken from EN 1993-1-8 Table 4.1

fuf_\mathrm{u}fu​ - nominal ultimate tensile strength of the weaker part joined

γM2\gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}γM2​ - partial safety factor for welds

HHH - IPE beam height

BBB - IPE beam width

twt_\mathrm{w}tw​ - IPE beam web thickness 

tft_\mathrm{f}tf​ - IPE beam flange thickness

Hand Calculation of bending moment M

In the calculation of bending moment without any interaction with shear force, the plastic section modulus of the whole weld section (both around flanges and around web) was assumed.

σ⊥2+3⋅(τ⊥2+τ∥2)≤fuβw⋅γM2\sqrt{ \sigma_{\perp}^2 + 3 \cdot \left( \tau_{\perp}^2 + \tau_{\parallel}^2\right)} \leq \frac{f_u}{\beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}}σ⊥2​+3⋅(τ⊥2​+τ∥2​)​≤βw​⋅γM2​fu​​

σ⊥=τ⊥=σN2=MW⋅12\sigma_{\perp} = \tau_{\perp} = \frac{\sigma_{N}}{\sqrt{2}} = \frac{M}{W}\cdot \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}}σ⊥​=τ⊥​=2​σN​​=WM​⋅2​1​

τ∥=0\tau_{\parallel} = 0τ∥​=0

(σN2)2+3⋅(σN2)2≤fuβw⋅γM2\sqrt{ \left( \frac{\sigma_{N}}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2 + 3 \cdot \left( \frac{\sigma_{N}}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2} \leq \frac{f_u}{\beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}}(2​σN​​)2+3⋅(2​σN​​)2​≤βw​⋅γM2​fu​​

(MW⋅12)2+3⋅(MW⋅12)2≤fuβw⋅γM2\sqrt{ \left( \frac{M}{W}\cdot \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2 + 3 \cdot \left( \frac{M}{W}\cdot \frac{1}{\sqrt{2}} \right)^2} \leq \frac{f_u}{\beta_{\mathrm{w}} \cdot \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}}(WM​⋅2​1​)2+3⋅(WM​⋅2​1​)2​≤βw​⋅γM2​fu​​

M≤fu⋅Wβw ⋅ γM2 ⋅ 2M \leq \frac{f_{u} \cdot W }{\beta_{\mathrm{w}}  \cdot  \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}  \cdot  \sqrt{2}}M≤βw​ ⋅ γM2​ ⋅ 2​fu​⋅W​

σ⊥≤fu ⋅ 0.9γM2\sigma_{\perp} \leq \frac{f_{u}  \cdot  0.9}{ \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}}σ⊥​≤γM2​fu​ ⋅ 0.9​

M≤fu ⋅ W ⋅ 0.9 ⋅ 2γM2M \leq \frac{f_{u}  \cdot  W  \cdot  0.9  \cdot  \sqrt{2}}{ \gamma_{\mathrm{M2}} }M≤γM2​fu​ ⋅ W ⋅ 0.9 ⋅ 2​​

Where:

aaa - weld throat thickness

WWW - weld plastic section module

MMM - the bending moment acting on the beam

βw\beta_{\mathrm{w}}βw​ - correlation factor taken from EN 1993-1-8 Table 4.1

fuf_ufu​ - nominal ultimate tensile strength of the weaker part joined

γM2\gamma_{\mathrm{M2}}γM2​ - partial safety factor for welds

 Numerical model

The weld component in CBFEM is described in General theoretical background and EN theoretical background. 

Nonlinear elastic-plastic material is used for welds in this study. The limit plastic strain is reached in longer part of the weld and stress peaks are redistributed.

Fig. 4.4.1 Joint’s geometry with dimensions\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 4.4.1 Joint’s geometry with dimensions}}}Fig. 4.4.1 Joint’s geometry with dimensions

 Verification of resistance

Design resistance calculated by CBFEM Idea RS software is compared with the results of CM. The weld’s design resistances are compared, see Tab. 4.4.2. The study is performed for one parameter beam section and three load cases: normal force NEd, shear force VEd, and bending moment MEd.

Tab. 4.4.2 Comparison of CBFEM and CM

Results of CBFEM and CM are compared and a sensitivity study is presented. The influence of beam cross-section on the design resistance a welded beam-to-column joint loaded in tension is shown in Fig. 4.4.2, in shear in Fig. 4.4.3 and in bending in Fig. 4.4.4. The study shows good agreement for all applied load cases.

Fig. 4.4.2\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 4.4.2}}}Fig. 4.4.2

Fig. 4.4.3\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 4.4.3}}}Fig. 4.4.3

Fig. 4.4.4\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 4.4.4}}}Fig. 4.4.4

To illustrate the accuracy of the CBFEM model, results of the sensitivity study is summarized in a diagram comparing CBFEM’s and CM’s design resistances, see Fig. 4.4.5. The results show that the difference of the two calculation methods is in all cases less than 10%.

Fig. 4.4.5 Verification of CBFEM to CM\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 4.4.5 Verification of CBFEM to CM}}}Fig. 4.4.5 Verification of CBFEM to CM

 Benchmark example

Inputs

Column

  • Steel S235
  • HEB 400

Beam

  •  Steel S235
  •  IPE 160
  •  Force eccentricity to weld x = 400 mm, see Fig. 4.4.6

Weld

  •   Throat thickness aw = 3 mm

Outputs:

  • Design resistance in shear VRd = 105 kN

Fig. 4.4.6 Benchmark example of the welded beam to column joint with force eccentricity\textsf{\textit{\footnotesize{Fig. 4.4.6 Benchmark example of the welded beam to column joint with force eccentricity}}}Fig. 4.4.6 Benchmark example of the welded beam to column joint with force eccentricity

Open in ViewerDownload